Sheila Izzo


Sheila and her husband relocated from the city over 25 years ago, making the choice to first start a local business in Cutchogue and then spend wonderful days raising three great sons on the beautiful North Fork. Sheila quickly became very active in local community pursuits including coaching baseball and summer soccer teams. She has been a volunteer on the Mattituck-Cutchogue Little League Board. She continues fundraising for local charities, schools and organizations in Southold and Riverhead as well. Sheila has been chairperson for numerous charitable events including local garden and fashion shows as well as golf and fishing outings. In addition to her volunteering activities, Sheila began her own design business which included designing beautiful and festive settings for homes, businesses and country clubs.

The love of architecture and beautiful surroundings was a natural lead-in for Sheila’s venture into the real estate industry. Over the years Sheila has combined her knowledge and deep affection for the East End with her real estate skills and talents, confident in her ability to help potential buyers find their own piece of heaven right here on the North Fork and assist sellers in professionally marketing their homes in any type of market.

Sheila has over ten years’ experience in the local North Fork real estate market. She has won many awards and earned the prestigious honor of being top producer. Sheila also wins her clients trust, confidence and return business with her professionalism, honesty and integrity.

Cellphone/Work Phone: 631.384.5551

Mission Statement

At North Fork Real Estate we are committed to treating our clients as people, not opportunities. To truly listen to and adapt our resources to your wishes. To always do the right thing, even when it may be difficult or less-profitable for us.

To leverage the latest tools, technologies and our own position as an independent agency to ensure we are providing the best service available anywhere to our clients.

To break the rules, or write new ones, when necessary. To adapt quickly as needed and provide a real estate experience that is both professional and personal. And, whether you are buying or selling, to completely meet your needs, whatever they may be.

What’s It Like To Work With Sheila?

Sheila was the listing agent on the house we purchased. From our first meeting through the entire purchase process she was wonderful to work with. She was always quick to respond to any question or request we had, and always made herself available if we needed to view the house. Shelia also provides us with a lot of helpful local knowledge which we really appreciated. She was a pleasure to work with and we would happily recommend her to anyone looking for a trustworthy broker on the North Fork.”

Sheila Izzo is a professional, reliable and honest realtor. She was very up front with us, gave us the information that she had so we could make an informed decision concerning the sale of the house.

I would recommend Sheila to anybody buying or selling a house. She is experienced and knows the market.”

“As the owner of several residential, investment and commercial properties on the North Fork , I have worked with Sheila for all my real estate needs.  Sheila is consistently responsive, informative and professional.  I have found that she will analyze each project individually to development a well-informed and creative approach to generate the best possible outcome.”

Sheila Izzo has a rare combination of professionalism, self assuredness and informality that makes the nerve wracking process of selling or buying a home markedly less so. When I was ready to accept a bid, she got me another $5,000 with one phone call. When we decided to rent our family’s bayfront home she found us a wonderful family that treats our house as their own. And they appear to be repeat customers. My experience with Sheila has been so positive that there is no chance I’d undertake a real estate transaction without her.”